OK, we’ve looked at Chapter One, studying something of the cultural and historical context of how this vision was given to the apostle John - probably in about AD96 on the island of Patmos whilst he was in exile under the Emperor Domitian. We’ve gone through some incredible theology about the nature of Christ, the Trinitarian God whom we worship and the nature of the church of God, past, present and future. We don’t need to recap on any of this again.
And now the letter from John changes a bit as we move away from the introductory vision and move towards the beginning of application to the church. And chapters 2 through to 4 are a group of letters; one to each of the seven churches to whom John is writing this corporate letter. As we noted, he was Bishop of Ephesus and had spiritual care over churches in Asia Minor, which is modern-day Turkey. And the letter is to go to seven of these: Ephesus, Smyra, Pergamum, Thyatira, Sardis, Philadelphia and Laodicia.
And these are not a random selection of churches and the order they come in is not random because there was a circular travelling route around Asia Minor and these churches are listed in the order that a messenger might go if he was to visit each one in turn. And the first city to be visited by the messenger is Ephesus.
OK, let’s have a brief look at the city of Ephesus; a brief bit of history so we can put the letter into some context before we look at the letter itself.
Introduction to the city of Ephesus
Ephesus, for many years, had a been a major city in the period when John’s letter was sent to them. There was a population of about 400,000- 500,000, which made it one of the largest cities in the Mediterranean world. There had been populations there since about 6000BC, the Neolithic Era and it is still a key area for archaeology relating to the Bronze Age era.
Ephesus was a great port city, built around the Kayster River and so it became a target for invading forces and, throughout the centuries, many armies had invaded Ephesus and taken it over. Probably as a result of this history, Ephesus was a pretty cosmopolitan city: it was multicultural and tolerant in its ethnic diversity. Eventually, though, it became part of the Roman Empire and the character of the city changed dramatically. The citizens were subjected to huge tax rises and the city was plundered of its treasures. For a short time, it became self-governing but just before the time of Christ it came back under Roman rule and became one of the most advanced cities in the world.
There was a huge theatre there which seated 25,000 people who might watch drama or they might watch gladiatorial games. There were huge public baths, a massive library and 4 major aqueducts. There were water mills, a sawmill and a marble factory too. By any account, Ephesus was a major city in the Roman Empire and we are not surprised that it was the site for a Temple of Domitian who was, as we have been thinking over the last few weeks, the Emperor at the time John received his vision of the Revelation.
But Ephesus was perhaps most famous for its Temple of Artemis that was completed about 550 BC and was one of the Seven Wonders of the World. Artemis was a Greek goddess, known as Diana to the Romans, and the temple worship was at the heart of the cultural life of the city. And so, with a Temple to Domitian and a Temple for Artemis, the Christians in Ephesus were daily confronted with pagan images and had to be absolutely sure and confident about who they wanted to worship: Jesus Christ, the Son of God.
And Ephesus had been a crucial centre for Christianity almost since its inception as a religious movement. Paul had lived there from AD 52-54 and he had organised some of his missionary journeys from there. As well as establishing the church he wrote his Letter to the Ephesians to in AD 62, when he was in prison in Rome. He probably wrote 1 Corinthians while he was there and we hear about one particular incident from the life of Paul in Ephesus in Acts 19:23-41. I won’t go through the story now – you can read it yourself later - but basically Paul had upset the workers who made shrines and statues dedicated to the goddess Artemis and, because of the rise of Christianity, they were fearful that they would lose their trade. There was a public disturbance and a meeting held in the theatre and, as a result, Paul had to leave the city quickly and head off for Macedonia. But the church continued to flourish anyway and by the time John sent this letter to them they were well established.
The seven letters
We are going to look at the detail of the letter in a minute but first, I want to make some comment about the seven letters together. We know that seven is the biblical number for wholeness and completeness and therefore these letters are written to seven separate, historical churches but they are also meant for every church – the whole church – throughout time. But there is also something interesting about how these letters are structured: there is a commonality of structure across them all, which you might want to briefly look at with me.
First, each letter begins with a description of Jesus Christ, which relates directly to the vision of Christ we studied last week in chapter 1. To Ephesus, he is “the one who holds the seven stars”. To Pergamum, he is the “one who has the sharp, double-edged sword”. To Thyatira, he is the one “with eyes like blazing fire” and so on…So, there is continuity of how Christ is being described here and, as we will go on to see, each description is related to the particular problem that each church faces. More of that later…
Second, each church (except Laodicea) is commended by Christ for something that they have done or continue to do.
Thirdly, each church (except Smyrna and Philadelphia) are criticised by Christ. And, as an aside, it’s good to see that the commendation always comes before the criticism and I think we have a lot to learn from that: because we are often too quick to criticise and too slow to commend which is not the way of Christ at all. In these letters, Jesus has something against the churches but he always builds them up first before critiquing them and we would do well to learn from that pattern.
Fourth, there is a corrective command given to each church: Jesus says to them, “This is your problem and this is what you must do about it”.
Fifth, there is a commitment given by Christ to those who obey his teaching.
So that is the structure to all the letters: Introduction, Commendation, Critique, Command, Commitment.
OK, that’s a long introduction! Let’s get into the letter to the believers at Ephesus.
The message to Ephesus
John starts in verse 1 by relaying Christ’s words: “To the angel of the church in Ephesus write…”
Now we had an interesting question from Yannick last week about what this reference to an angel means and I think the answer is the same as it was in 1:20. The word ‘angel’ here means ‘messenger’ and can be taken either as the leaders of the church or those preaching the Gospel there or even the messenger who would receive the letter at Ephesus and read it out to the congregation. We will be meeting angels from the heavenly realm later in Revelation but I don’t think that’s what is referred to here.
“These are the words of him who holds the seven stars in his right hand and walks among the seven golden lampstands.” This is imagery we thought about last week, so we don’t need to repeat it here. But we remind ourselves that this is a symbol of God’s power and a encouragement that he is in control of the destiny of his church. Remember last week, that Domitian’s son, who had died in infancy, was pictured on the back of coins, juggling seven stars as an indication that he had become a divine being. But we are reminded here that it is Jesus who holds the seven stars and he is in control.
We learnt last week that the seven golden lampstands are the seven churches, representative of the church throughout time and this is an encouragement that God is with us always. But there is one subtle difference in 2:1 from 1:13. In 1:13, we are told that Jesus was “among” the lampstands, indicating his presence with them. But in 2:1, we are told he “walks among” the lampstands and this is an important difference because what is being indicated here is that Jesus is active in his churches and his activity will never end. [John’s use of the present active participle is different from the present active tense: the former suggests a never-ending activity, the latter an activity that will come to an end]. Jesus is not just a benign presence in the church. He is actively walking among us, working in his church, stirring us up, encouraging us, leading us by his Spirit. Jesus Christ is our High Priest and his priestly work continues in our midst and I guess there is something of a challenge here, a rhetorical question that we need to answer: “Where is Jesus Christ at work in our church?” If we asked the question, “Is Christ in our midst?”, the answer is clearly, ‘Yes’. But to ask the question, “Where is Jesus Christ at work in our church?” demands a different response from us and a different perspective on our community life together.
Let’s move on to verse 2: “I know your deeds, your hard work and your perseverance.” This triad is not unique to Revelation in the New Testament. In 1 Thessalonians 1:3, for example, Paul says, “We continually remember before our God and Father your work produced by faith, your labour prompted by love, and your endurance inspired by hope in our Lord Jesus Christ”. Deeds, toil and perseverance seemed to be hallmarks of a congregation that was pursuing Christ. But what do these words mean?
The word used for ‘work’ or ‘deeds’ is the root word for our word ‘energy’ and it seems that the church in Ephesus was indeed an energetic church, a busy church, a church that others would look at and say, “Wow! There’s loads going on there!” It’s a word that indicates practical labour: manual labour, the workers in the vineyard effort, activity. Ephesus was a church that was known for what it did and presumably other congregations were in awe at all they managed to achieve.
“I know your deeds, your toil…” The word here for toil doesn’t just mean hard work: it means working yourself to the point of exhaustion! It sounds like Ephesus was a ‘Purpose Driven Church’ dedicating themselves to Christian ministry, taking themselves to the verge of complete exhaustion.
“I know your deeds, your toil and your perseverance”. Perseverance here refers to the ability to stand one’s ground in the face of attack. Now, we might think that the attack which they are persevering is the Domitian persecution: that Christ is commending them for their ability to withstand physical and economic persecution. But the rest of the verse seems to imply something different and a bit disconcerting, really: “I know your deeds, your toil and your perseverance. I know that you cannot tolerate wicked men, that you have tested those who claim to be apostles but are not, and have found them false.”
Actually, what we have here is a picture of a church that is absolutely driven by the desire to retain doctrinal purity: a church that is so intent on pursuing orthodox faith and practice and keeping out any false witness that they have pushed themselves to the point of exhaustion! Now, let’s unpack this a bit because there is something positive to be explored here but something negative too and it is at the very heart of what we are studying tonight.
Firstly, we need to consider the positive aspect of this - and it is positive, because Jesus is commending them for this. The church at Ephesus that was developing in a multicultural environment with a diversity of religious and philosophical views, the church that was emerging in the shadow of the Temples dedicated to Domitian and Artemis, knew that they had to hold fast to the truths about Christianity. They could not allow the faith to be watered down by endorsing pagan idolatry or false doctrines. They needed to stay true to Christ and were determined to root out false teaching.
So who were these false teachers who needed to be opposed? If we look at the evidence of the other letters in the New Testament and also some references within Revelation that we will come to another day, it seems that the Ephesians were opposing a group called The Gnostics. Now we can’t unpack Gnostic teaching too much right now but they saw themselves as a very ‘spiritual’ sect. They were concerned with the heavenly Jesus rather than the earthly Jesus. They appealed to the Spirit of God for the revelation of truth rather than the experience and words of the apostles. They believed that there were secrets and mysteries in the heart of God that could only be revealed to a select few, through special rituals. Gnosticism was rife in the early church and lots of the New Testament is written and developed in opposition to Gnosticism.
Well, in verse 2, Jesus says, “I know you cannot tolerate wicked men…” and we might think that it’s a bit of an over-reaction to call them ‘wicked’ just because they were not doctrinally pure. But what is being condemned here is not so much their beliefs but what resulted from their beliefs.
Gnostics believed that the body (made of matter) is essentially evil and the spirit (housed within the body) is essentially pure and that resulted in one of two activities: Some Gnostics went in for asceticism, which means they tried to overcome their bodies through extreme spiritual practices like fasting, self-flagellation, living in solitary places and so on. But other Gnostics went to the other extreme and said that, if the body is evil, it can’t affect the spirit which is pure and so they went in for orgies and drunkenness and excessive behaviours. And it is these two extremes that are condemned here as being evil and not to be tolerated in the church.
And, in the light of the Gnostic challenge, Jesus says in verse 3: “You have persevered and have endured hardship for my name, and have not grown weary.” These Christians in Ephesus are being commended by Christ for holding fast to the truth of the Christian doctrines. They would not tolerate doctrines that led to a false spirituality and, even though they had toiled, they had not yet grown weary.
We have something to learn here, I think, about the importance of holding fast to the Christian message. Like the church in Ephesus, we are surrounded on every side by the temptation to relativise the Gospel, by tolerating lax behaviour that is unbecoming of the church but also, by tolerating practices that are ‘too extreme’ in their spirituality. There is a middle way that Christ calls us to follow and like the Ephesians, we need to be zealous for that.
But…
…Jesus is not entirely happy with the Ephesian church, verse 4: “Yet I hold this against you: You have forsaken your first love”. The sad truth is, that the Ephesians were so determined to be doctrinally pure that they had forgotten the very heart of the Gospel. They were so determined to keep to the truth of the Gospel that they had forgotten the centrality of love. The church at Ephesus had fallen into a common trap: Christian activity is not the same as Christian love.
“You have forsaken your first love.”
What does Jesus mean by this? What love is he referring to? There are at least three different opinions about this…
Some commentators think it refers to their love for Jesus himself; that in all their busyness, they had forgotten all about Jesus.
Some commentators believe that it refers to their love for each other; that their activity meant their were driven by programs, not people.
Other commentators think it refers to a love of humanity in general; that they were devoted to evangelistic activities but were more concerned to ‘win souls’ than to ‘love people’.
It’s difficult to isolate any one of these and perhaps all three of them are right.
“You have forsaken your first love”.
You have become so busy doing Christian things that you have neglected love for Christ. You have neglected love for each other. You have neglected love for the world.
And this provides us with a deep moment of self-reflection because the truth is that this forsaking of our first love creeps up on us over a period of time. We may be so busy at church, preparing so many sermons, going to so many prayer meetings, involving ourselves in so many youth groups and worship groups, being on so many committees, that we think we are doing it all out of love and commitment. But actually, over a period of time, the love has decreased and the activity has increased. If we get off the merry-go-round for just a moment, we see that love has very little to do with our motivation and that, actually, we are just caught up in a round of busyness.
But that’s not where we started, is it? If we look back, each one of us began out of a desire to love and to serve but, over a period of time, the motivation has imperceptively changed and we can’t even pinpoint a time when it began to happen…
This is not the life Jesus has called us to; no matter how well intentioned we are, no matter how much zeal we have in pursuing the doctrines of Christ, no matter how much we may love the church, if we are not motivated by love, this is not the life Jesus has called us to. What does Paul say in 1 Corinthians 13? “If I speak in the tongues of men and of angels, but have not love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but have not love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and surrender my body to the flames, but have not love, I gain nothing.”
A salutary warning…
But, in this Book of Revelation, Christ gives us an option to right this wrong in our lives. “Remember the height from which you have fallen! Repent and do the things you did at first.” If you like your sermons to have three points all starting with the same letter, we can talk about the three R’s: Remember, Repent, Repeat. Let’s just think briefly about these three:
First, they are called to Remember…A number of years earlier, Paul had written to the church at Ephesus and in Ephesians 1:15 Paul says, “I heard about your faith in the Lord Jesus and your love for all the saints…” The church at Ephesus had been known for its love! In Ephesians 6:24, Paul says, “Grace to all who love our Lord Jesus Christ with an undying love”. The church at Ephesus had been known for its love! In Ephesians 4:2, Paul writes, “Bear with one another in love”. The church at Ephesus had been known for its love! In Ephesians 4:15, Paul writes that they are “speaking the truth in love”. The church at Ephesus had been known for its love!
But now, at John writes to them in AD 96, they had forgotten how to love. They had become so busy, so absorbed with doctrinal purity, they had forgotten how to love.
They needed to Remember…and having remembered, they needed to Repent. The word Repent is very interesting: it’s not just about saying sorry…it basically means that we are walking in one direction and we need to stop, turn round and walk back in the other direction. Repentance is a definite moment of decision and an act of the will. We recognise that we are heading the wrong way and we make a conscious decision to turn around and head the other way. Having remembered the height they had fallen from, the church at Ephesus needed to repent: to make a conscious decision to stop, turn round and walk the other way.
And so, having remembered and repented, they needed to repeat the things they did at first. Of course, it would be easy for them to read that and think that they had to undertake a new type of activity. We are so geared up towards activity that it is hard for us to think any differently: “What does God want me to do for him?” That’s not the question. “What does God want me to be for him?” - that’s the question!
Remember. Repent. Repeat. That is the calling on each one of us from this passage. And Jesus follows this up with a warning in verse 5: “If you do not repent, I will come to you and remove your lampstand from its place”.
Quite simply, it doesn’t matter how busy we might be as a church, unless we are motivated by love, the light will go out. Sure, we can continue to fool people and to amaze people with how much we do and how much we seem to achieve but if we are not motivated by love, the light will have gone out. What a terrible thought…
We are coming to the end now and I want to avoid verse 6 at this point: “But you have this in your favour: You hate the practices of Nicolaitans, which I also hate”. We can afford to skip this verse because 2:15, we will come across the Nicolaitans again and we can deal with them in more depth there. But finally, I want to just comment on the promise of God in 2:7: “He who has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the churches. To him who overcomes, I will give the right to eat from the tree of life, which is in the paradise of God.”
Here, Jesus calls us back to the Garden of Eden and his promise to us is that creation at the last will be as creation at the beginning. Salvation is a cyclical event: for those who are saved in Christ, we are going full circle. What we lost in Adam will be restored to us in Christ. The tree of life that is promised to us, if we obey his words is the promise of eternal life. But its important that we are told it is “in the paradise of God”.
The word ‘Paradise’ was originally a Persian word, which means a ‘walled garden’ or a ‘park surrounded by a wall’. So it speaks to us of the protection of God. Paradise is eternal life, where we are walled in by the love of God, we are protected by him, made safe and secure in him and this, of course, is yet another word of encouragement for the first hearers: dispelling their fears and anxieties.
So, as we have come to expect from the Book of Revelation, in just a few short verses we are confronted with deep theological truths: That God holds us in his hands, that God is not just present in his church, but active in his church, that he commends the pursuit of purity and doctrinal orthodoxy, that he wants us to stand firm in the face of false teaching and idolatry, that we are not to lose our love in the midst of all our busyness, that we are to undertake self-reflection to remember, to repent, to repeat what we once did, who we once were, that, if we don’t the light will go out and Christ will no longer walk amongst us, that if we pursue love, we will share in eternal life and be protected and walled in by the love of God for all eternity. Incredible truths and much for us to reflect on…
As a footnote, you may wonder what happened to the church at Ephesus. How does the story end? Well, certainly they responded because only 20 years later, Bishop Ignatius of Antioch wrote to them and said: “…to the church which is at Ephesus, in Asia, deservedly most happy, being blessed in the greatness and fullness of God the Father, and predestinated before the beginning of time, that it should be always for an enduring and unchangeable glory”.
But the long -term history was not as encouraging…In 614, the city was partially destroyed in an earthquake and then the harbour became silted up, so it lost its importance as a commercial centre. In the 8th-century, its fortunes declined further and by the time of the 11th-century Turkish conquest, it was just a small village.
Ephesus then went into extinction, and the church with it, but the neighbouring town was known – and is known – as Ayasaluk, which means ‘Saint-Theologian’ – a reference to the apostle John. Ephesus no longer exists. The church no longer exists there - but the legacy of John lives on and it is that legacy, this vision, this teaching, that we reflect on tonight and allow God to challenge us through so that we might glorify his name in our own lives and in our church.